Authentic Italian flavors, a crackling pizza oven, and 1,600+ happy diners agree it's worth every mile.
At Cosimo's, the wood-fired oven isn't a gimmick. It's the centerpiece of the dining room, glowing warm while plates of fresh tagliatelle Bolognese and golden focaccia make their way to packed tables on a Friday night. Regulars come back not just for the food but for the full Italian-American experience: candlelight, the smell of charred crust, and servers who remember your usual order by visit three.
Situated right on NY-32 in Central Valley, Cosimo's draws diners from across the Hudson Valley and beyond. A 4.5-star rating built on more than 1,600 reviews isn't luck. It's the result of a kitchen that takes the classics seriously and a front-of-house team that makes every guest feel like a regular, whether it's their first visit or their fifteenth.
The menu spans the full Italian table, from crisp Caesar salads shaved generously with Parmigiano to wood-fired pies with blistered, chewy crusts. Pair your meal with a glass of red wine or a cold draft pint and settle in. There's no rush here.
Cosimo's menu is built around the wood-fired pizza oven, and every pie shows it. Dough is stretched thin, loaded with quality toppings, and finished in the kind of high heat that produces that signature char and chew you just can't replicate in a conventional oven. Whether you're ordering a classic Margherita or something more loaded, the crust alone is worth the trip.
Beyond pizza, the kitchen delivers a full Italian menu: handmade fresh pasta, house salads, antipasto, and entrées that cover the comfort-food spectrum from hearty Bolognese to lighter seasonal plates. The bar pours a solid selection of wines and draft beers, including Guinness on tap, so the meal can start long before the food arrives.
Cosimo's is open seven days a week, from 11:30 AM through the evening, making it equally suited for a weekday lunch, a casual family dinner, or a late-night Friday meal that stretches well past the first bottle of wine.
Take a look at our space and what we have to offer
Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers
Cosimo's is open Monday through Thursday 11:30 AM to 10:00 PM, Friday and Saturday 11:30 AM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday 12:00 PM to 10:00 PM. They are open all seven days of the week.
Cosimo's is located at 100 NY-32 in Central Valley, NY 10917, right along the main highway with convenient access from throughout the Hudson Valley region.
Yes. The wood-fired oven is central to both the menu and the atmosphere. It produces the high heat needed for properly blistered, chewy pizza crusts and is visible from the dining room.
Absolutely. The menu includes fresh pasta dishes like tagliatelle Bolognese, house salads, antipasto, and a variety of Italian entrees. There is also a full bar with wine, draft beer, and cocktails.
Reservations are recommended, especially on Friday and Saturday evenings when the dining room fills up. You can visit cosimoswoodbury.com for more information or to plan your visit.
Yes. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, the menu has broad appeal, and the kitchen is used to accommodating tables of all sizes. It works equally well for a casual family dinner or a date night out.
Consistently well-reviewed. Multiple guests who have visited three or more times note that the service remains attentive and personal across visits. The front-of-house staff contribute meaningfully to the overall experience.
Real neighbors nearby, each with their own site. Tap any one to visit it directly.
40 Jersey Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY 10925, USA
399 N Lake Shore Dr, Hewitt, NJ 07421, USA
1555 US-511, 1555 Greenwood Lake Turnpike, Hewitt, NJ 07421, USA
1926 Union Valley Rd, Hewitt, NJ 07421, USA
1849 County Rd 511, Hewitt, NJ 07421, USA
Other pizza restaurant spots near here. Tap one to open its page.